One time, I asked the girls to clean their room (I wanted to vacuum the upstairs) and they agreed. 10 minutes later, nothing had happened. They were playing in their room and had made the floor even messier than before. They got distracted! I was, admittedly, frustrated. I resorted to nagging, which really didn't work. In the end, I stood there whilst they did the job. It was not a positive experience for any of us. Afterwards, I reflected and I really disliked how I reacted. I didn't shout, but I could have been more understanding to why they got distracted and what I should have done differently.
There's a version of this that every parent knows: you ask your child to do something, they groan, you nag, they do a half-hearted job, you end up doing it yourself. Rinse and repeat until everyone's exhausted and vaguely annoyed at each other.
That's not what this post is about. Or rather — it's about how to get out of that loop.
Why children don't help (and it's not laziness)
Most children aren't unhelpful because they're selfish. They're unhelpful because they don't see themselves as part of the system. The household just runs, food appears, clothes get washed, and none of it has anything to do with them.
When children feel like passengers rather than crew members, they behave accordingly. They don't help because they never felt anybody genuinely needed their help. The trick isn't better nagging — it's changing the frame entirely.
I regret to say, it took me far too long to realise this. When I was speaking to my girls and asking why I had to keep chasing them, their responses were often not defensive. It didn't matter whether it was my eldest or youngest, it went along the lines of 'I keep forgetting" or "I get distracted." On one of the last occasions, one said "it get's done anyway.' That's when I realised that these were not the 'excuses' I had thought they were, but rather they just didn't feel like they owned it. That's when, together with my wife, I looked for a new approach.
Age-appropriate involvement from the start
Children as young as two can help. Not usefully, necessarily, but they can be involved. A toddler handing you pegs while you hang washing feels like a participant. A three-year-old putting their plate in the dishwasher has done a real job. The key word is "real" — they need to feel that what they're doing actually matters, not that they're being kept busy while the adults do the actual work.
As they get older, the jobs get bigger. A six-year-old can unpack the shopping. A nine-year-old can prepare a simple meal with supervision. A twelve-year-old can take genuine ownership of something — a room, a pet, a weekly task — without being supervised at all.
This last weekend, we had both our daughters do the majority of their pet's hutch clean. It was messy and we had a lot of sweeping to do afterwards, but they did it and took pride in ensuring their beloved pets had a clean home.
Make the work visible
One of the most underrated changes you can make is making household work visible. Most of it is invisible — it happens when children aren't watching, it gets done before they're up or after they're in bed, and the end result (a tidy house, food in the fridge) is just the background of their life.
When you show children the work — talk them through the mental load of a weekly shop, let them see you planning meals, explain why the bathroom needs cleaning — the household stops being magic and becomes something they can understand and contribute to.
This doesn't mean burdening them with adult worries. It means including them in the reality of running a home. That's why we've made clearing up after dinner a family thing. Even if it's just putting the dishes in the sink at the end.
The chore chart problem
Most chore charts fail (some sources say within a month). This isn't a parenting failure — it's a design failure. The chart goes on the fridge, everyone's enthusiastic, and then life happens and the chart becomes wallpaper. It goes out of date, we get busy, and the early momentum is then lost.
What tends to work better:
- Keep it simple. Fixed jobs, not rotating ones. When a child "owns" a task — the bins are always their job, they always feed the pet— they stop waiting to be told and start just doing it. Rotating jobs means everyone is always waiting for someone to assign it.
- Connecting the job to the outcome. "You're in charge of the kitchen bin" lands differently than "empty the bin." The first creates ownership; the second creates a task.
- Not over-engineering it. A simple list of who does what, visible and agreed, beats any elaborate reward system that requires maintenance to sustain.
We have fixed jobs. They are a mix between daily, weekly, and monthly. We try a wonderful looking bespoke chore board we bought. But that failed after a couple of weeks. We had to keep resetting it or un 'ticking' a task as it wasn't done fully. In the end, I developed the Chore module in Harthena. I perhaps over engineered it, so my wife stepped in and helped me simplify it. Now, it's consistent and they have their own tasks.
The children started to chase us for tasks before we even finished entering it onto the system.
Involving children in decisions, not just tasks
The biggest lever I've found isn't assigning more tasks — it's including children in decisions. What should we have for dinner this week? Should we get the big tin of beans or the small ones? Do we need more of this?
When children help plan the shopping, they're less likely to reject what appears on the table. When they choose a meal, they have a stake in making it. When they help decide how Saturday morning works, they're not fighting against a plan imposed on them — they're part of the plan.
My two can be temperamental. Sometimes willing to try new things, and other times discounting a meal just on sight. We've tried many things, having it self-serve on the table, gradual repetition of new things, and asking them all up front. We found asking them to get involved in planning the meals of the week (whilst setting guidelines so we didn't just get 'pizza' every night), helped to ensure they kept trying new things. When I developed the meal planner, that really engaged them to put forward their own ideas. When we have new things that they like, they ask me to get my camera and upload a picture so that they remember next time. Whilst it hasn't solved all issues at dinner time, it has certainly helped us.
When it goes wrong
It won't always work. Some days they'll flatly refuse. Some days the "their job" thing will slide and you'll end up doing it yourself because it's quicker. Some weeks the whole system falls apart and you start again from scratch.
That's fine. The goal isn't a perfect household. It's children who grow up understanding that a home takes work, that everyone in it has a role, and that helping each other is just what families do.
Tension or frustration, does still arise. But every time, I see one my children putting their plate away, preparing food for our guinea pig, or offering to help put washing away; all without asking; I remind myself that it's working, they are learning and growing. These are the moments worth holding onto.
If you relate to any of this, give Harthena a try for free — no card needed. I built it for exactly this.
Try Harthena with your family
Pocket money, chores, meal planning, and a shared family calendar — all in one place. Free to start.